In the book I'm working on, I have used a narrative model to describe cider, focusing in on traditional cider makers from various places in Europe and the US. In the charts below, you can see how they stack up in terms of temperature and rainfall. I selected the places based on the cideries I covered in my book, throwing in Fennville, Michigan as a final entrant, even though I didn't visit Virtue Cider. It's on the coast of Lake Michigan. (I did speak with Greg Hall and the cidery is mentioned in the book.) You could add a lot more lines to the chart--Oviedo, Asturias, Yakima, Virginia--but this seems to illustrate things well enough.
Let's look first at average high temperatures, which are relevant during the growing season. At the height of the growing season, there's a ten-degree difference between England (72) and all the US locations, which interestingly have average highs of 82. That's the widest gap. Spring temps are warmer in Spain, but similar in the other locations.
I was especially interested in the lows, because in traditional cider-making, the juice is fermented naturally. Temperatures that are too low would halt that process without intervention, while high temperatures would put the ferment at risk. (All the Europeans do natural fermentation, as do EZ Orchards in Salem, Virtue in Fennville, and although Farnum Hill pitches yeast, they don't have much temperature control.) Michigan and New Hampshire are real outliers here, but Oregon and the European countries stay largely within a few degrees of one another.
Finally, rainfalls are pretty similar, too, except for insanely wet San Sebastian in the Basque Country, which is a wetter city than New Orleans. The rainfall patterns are different: Oregon's dry in the summer, Bristol in the Spring, and Lisieux in the winter. San Sebastian is never dry, and New Hampshire and Michigan get fairly even precipitation throughout the year.
It's not easy to draw big conclusions, but I pass it along for your edification nevertheless.
I'm color blind so I can't make out much of the chart, but I believe EZ Orchards has glycol jacketed fermenters so the temps don't quite matter so much for the Salem fermentation section.
ReplyDeleteJust curious, why didn't you include Eastern Washington/Yakima in your climate analysis? With irrigation, the rainfall chart wouldn't be terribly useful, but the temperature charts might be.
ReplyDeleteAndy and Jason, you both touch on things I considered as I was putting this together. It was pretty easy to figure the European locations and places on the East Coast and Midwest.
ReplyDeleteThe Pac NW is harder because cider making rarely happens where the apples are grown. It would be interesting to throw Hood River in there, because there are now a few Hood River cideries. Yakima, though, despite being responsible for the vast majority of American apples, doesn't really have cider makers. FWIW, Hood River gets about 31 inches of rain and has a climate pretty similar to Salem's.
I wonder if the chill in Michigan and NH affect the cider produced there. Is the effect similar for Canadian ice wine?
ReplyDelete"Good apples" is obviously general and relative, but I'd argue that tree ripeness and Brix improve in the "extreme" climates like New England, where we have cold nights and warm days during the autumn -- pre-harvest for the later, best cider apple varieties. And that, to me, makes a bigger difference in quality than average temps during fermentation.
ReplyDelete