You love the blog, so subscribe to the Beervana Podcast on iTunes or Soundcloud today!

Tuesday, November 08, 2011

Is Fuller's Craft Beer?

I'm kidding, halfty. We've already had far too may armchair philosophers and linguists weigh in on the question. And yet, on a day that included an absolutely glorious tour of the venerable Fuller's Brewery here in Chiswick, London (that's chizz-ick to you yanks) and a craft-brewery pub, the specter haunted us.

Fuller's is a 166-year-old independent brewery that produces a stellar line of cask ales as well as uber crafty offerings like strong ales and their "Past Masters" series based on historical recipes from the vaults. (The flagship is London Pride, one of the finest best bitters I know and, despite its modest strength, possibly my favorite.) They're one of the larger cask ale producers, but they're roughly the size of Widmer or Deschutes.

They are a perfect example of the difference between the US and British markets, though. Because, while no American would exclude them from the "craft" category, that's the bias they face in England. At the craft brew-focused pub we visited last night, they scoffed at Fuller's: too old.

That age is a huge part of it's virtue. I sat down with John Keeling and the shadowy figure with whom I'm traveling (he gave me permission to out him--some of you know him as the beeronomist--but shadowy figure amuses me), and listened to the history of Fuller's transformation thirty years ago into a modern facility.

Fuller's was until that time brewing beer on an ancient system--one the brewery preserved as a kind of museum-within-a-brewery. This is one of those decisions I take it the tradition-steeped British don't take lightly. Yet here's what British brewers confront: a steadily declining market for ales (currently 14%, according to Keeling) in which cask is just one niche (the famous "flat, warm" beer of England now commands just 8% of the whole market). For the first time in centuries, the proportion of beer consumed in pubs dropped below 50% this year. Those who hew exclusively to tradition in this market risk the oblivion of such titanic names as Bass, Whitbread, and Courage.

Fuller's modernized the brewery, which now looks like a standard American craft brewery. But interspersed throughout the modern stainless steel tuns and tanks are the earlier relics--copper equipment with the burnished patina of age.

Keeling offered a bit of analysis that parsed the "craft" question nicely. You want the beer to be clean and consistent on the one hand, flavorful and characterful on the other. Industrial breweries emphasize the former but not the latter. The antiquated coppers delivered the latter, but it was harder to achieve the former. Weirdly, I think this means the ultratraditionalists also ding Fuller's.

From my perspective, Fuller's is the model craft brewery. Eventually, the current crop of craft breweries won't be new anymore. Then they'll be judged purely on their beer. If they work hard and are very lucky, they'll be mentioned in Fuller's company.


  1. There are not many brewers in the world with a lineup as fine as Bengal Lancer, ESB, 1845, Vintage Ale, London Pride and London Porter.

  2. Had a great day at the Chiswick brewery last year. My tourguide was a randy old retiree from the brewery. On my tour was an attractive Swedish woman in her late 50s. The tourguide had the hots for her. When we got to the tasting in the cellars at the end, he started pulling out all kinds of beers and schwag to impress her. He was too polite to not include me. Drank a lot.

  3. It's post-craft.

    Er, I mean pre-craft.

  4. Excellent assessment, and I agree wholeheartedly.
    It's too bad that so many "craft" brewers can't even come close to achieving the excellence that Fuller's consistently offers.
    Anyway, I'm definitely not in the camp that defines "craft" brewing by the size of the brewery.

    The craft of any brewer is proven by what's poured into the glass and as good beer becomes more and more mainstream, that marketing term ("craft") will become obsolete since in its present form, it is hardly a guarantee of quality.

  5. I have a big soft spot for Fuller's, largely because my dad's family are from the Chiswick area, but also because they make really good beer.

    I think with a lot of the new breed of London based beer geeks, Fuller's suffers from a case of familiarity breeding contempt.

    From my perspective, I know that every time I drink any of their beers, I am going to be satisfied.

    The day Fuller's is declared non-craft is the day that beer geekery has disappeared up its own backside, and the world will not be worse off for it.